Whilst we plan for our forthcoming debate (finding out which pOp single and album you vote for as your number one for 2008), we thought we'd fill in some time by putting to rest one of the oldest and most bitter debates in pOp... Both Madonna and Kylie purists have long argued the allure of both of these ladies of pOp, but we thought we might just find out just WHAT the balance is...? So who is it for you? The 'singing budgie'? The 'material girl'? Who reigns supreme in YOUR pOp world!? Is it Madonna? Is it Kylie? Have you say with the voting panel in the right hand column! We'll bring you the results in early October.
Whilst we plan for our forthcoming debate (finding out which pOp single and album you vote for as your number one for 2008), we thought we'd fill in some time by putting to rest one of the oldest and most bitter debates in pOp... Both Madonna and Kylie purists have long argued the allure of both of these ladies of pOp, but we thought we might just find out just WHAT the balance is...? So who is it for you? The 'singing budgie'? The 'material girl'? Who reigns supreme in YOUR pOp world!? Is it Madonna? Is it Kylie? Have you say with the voting panel in the right hand column! We'll bring you the results in early October.
6 comments:
There is no question!
Kylie all the way for me.
Having been a fan since Locomtion I have watched Kylie grow as an artist & become the world's leading popstar.
How an artist relates to her fans also sways my choice.
Even though I like madonna (especially early stuff), I feel that an artist with a huge fan base in Australia IGNORE her local fans by not bringing the last 4 tours to these shores is a utter disgrace - if she wanted to come here she would make it happen.
Madonna doesnt get my vote on this one!!
kylie's music is always fresh and new
GAH! I can't decide.
I voted for Kylie - but every time I consider it more - I get more and more unsure of myself!
KYLIE KYLIE KYLIE !
Her Versatility is what Madonna never had nor She grown into a all rounder Singer & Pop icon as KYLIE!
so its: KYLIE MINOGUE!
Money talks in this case. Who has sold more records?
Uh, yeah, that'd be Madonna.
Who has managed to sell albums and singles consistently in America?
Yep. Madonna.
I don't like putting the two up against each other because I actually find both of them to be VERY different artists (I could play the whole "Madonna is in more control of her own career than Kylie is" card as well, but I won't) but, at the end of it all, there's no question that Madonna still reigns supreme. I don't see Kylie stealing Madonna's Queen Of Pop crown, nor do I think Kylie cares for it either.
I do find it a little funny people are actually bold enough to deny Madonna of her Pop icon status in comparison to Kylie's. This has made me giggle.
I CHANGE MY MIND!
Madonna is the Queen of pop - who has released more successful tracks & who has changed the most?
Madonna is the Queen of Reinvention and she doesn't follow trends - she makes them!
Like A Virgin, Like A Prayer, Vogue, Music, Hung Up, Burning Up, La Isla Bonita e.t.c. - Need I Go On?
Post a Comment